PO Box 26, Menemsha, MA 02552

PO Box 26, Menemsha, MA 02552

Available Property

Vineyard Haven - 92 Main Street

On Sale $1,890,000 - Single Family
6330 sq ft 7 Bedrooms6 Bathrooms1 Garages Print this page

The Captain Dexter House, ca. 1843, has a storied history. Originally owned by one of the Island whaling captains, this home has had several iterations, including the most recent in 2004 when a 3 story addition completed the restoration of this charming historic residence set in the heart of the seaside village of Vineyard Haven. The restoration included the preservation of the original architectural details while bringing the home into the present century with the addition of the country kitchen including a large center island and top of the line appliances, informal dining area and family room with a fireplace and access to the garden patio. Conveniences include a walk-in pantry, powder room and full bath, and laundry room. Formal and informal living areas can be found throughout the house as well as seven bedrooms and six and one-half baths. There are five working fireplaces including the master bedroom suite. All mechanical systems have been completely updated including central AC. Exterior living areas feature a balcony off the second floor sitting area, covered porch with views of the harbor, newly fenced bluestone patio with mature plantings, tiered perennial gardens and private parking for 3 cars. Theater, restaurants, boating and the beach are within footsteps of this gracious in-town residence. Walk to the library and elementary school. Offered fully furnished with a list of exclusions, attached. Substantial rental history. VIEW VIDEO UNDER EXTERNAL LINKS AT LOWER RIGHT.

The full basement under the new section includes a wine cellar, workshop, storage with 10 foot ceilings, gas furnace and hot water heater; crawl and full basement under original structure with oil heating for the front portion of the house. There are 4 heating zones (3 propane, 1 oil) and a 3 zone central air conditioning system, plus window units. Exterior bulkhead.

1st Floor
The gracious foyer greets you as you step into the home from the covered porch. The east facing living room grants a view of the harbor through the angled bay window. The patina of the original floors and the formal fireplace add to the warmth of this lovely room. Step through the wet bar to the inviting dining room with a wall of windows admitting an abundance of natural light. Then onto the family room with a fireplace and raised hearth, French doors leading to the patio and an informal dining area. The gourmet kitchen has a European flair with open shelving, soapstone counters, a 6 burner gas stove with grill and pot faucet, an oversize center island and top of the line appliances. Adjacent to the kitchen is a full bath and dedicated laundry room.

2nd Floor
The second floor can be accessed from the front foyer or a stairway from the family room. The front bedroom has views of the harbor, en suite bath and fireplace. Two of the bedrooms share a Jack and Jill bath with double sinks and tile floors. Situated towards the back of the house is a sunny family/TV room that offers access to a private balcony deck.

Listed by Coldwell Banker Landmarks

Property Map

Jessie Holtham

Jessie Holtham

A Maine native, she washed-ashore the island in 2002. Jessie says, "Martha's Vineyard often feels like a miniature Maine." Her passion and background is rooted in coastal biology, shellfish restoration, and she created the Martha's Vineyard Shell Recovery Partnership in collaboration with the MV Shellfish Group. A sales agent is the sum of their parts, and Jessie's active outdoor lifestyle - exploring land and sea while enjoying hobbies of trail biking, kayaking, fishing and surfing - has taken her to all corners of Martha's Vineyard. At the end of the day she has the pleasure of working and socializing at the local brew-pub. She urges you to explore with her and find your place.

Please contact the office for an agent to help you.

  • Office : 508-645-2658