PO Box 26, Menemsha, MA 02552

PO Box 26, Menemsha, MA 02552

Find Your Home

West Tisbury – 5 Murphys Lane

Murphy Exterior
On Sale
$1,625,000 - Single Family Home

Magical West Tisbury – Surrounded by conservation land with exquisite pastoral views and privacy, this nearly 3200 square foot former homestead of Island artist, Stan Murphy, is the ideal Vineyard property. The view out the back is of a gorgeous pond and grazing cows.

More Details
3180 sq ft  6 Bedrooms 3.5 Bathrooms 1 Garages
Choose Feiner Real Estate to work for you as a your  Buyer's Agent for any of these additional available properties. Call us today at 508 645-2658, or email, feinermv@gmail.com, for more information or to arrange a showing.

West Tisbury - 1076 State Road

IMG_1969
$850,000 - Commercial

An Iconic West Tisbury commercial property, the Bodfish Blacksmith House, built circa 1700 has been at the heart of all things Vineyard. Currently used as a multi-use commercial property with 2 residential apartments and 2 commercial units it has been a mainstay to the Wes

More Details
1750 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 62 Naushon Road

IMG_1969
$1,395,000 - Single Family

MODERN BEACH HOUSE - 200 Steps To Private Beach! This alluring modern beach house sits on over an acre in the desirable Upper Makonikey Association off Lamberts Cove Road, and is only steps to a stunning privately-owned North Shore beach. Enjoy swimming, fishing and breatht

More Details
2625 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 18 Solviva Road

IMG_1969
$1,595,000 - Single Family

A rare opportunity to purchase this very special property on just under 10 acres in West Tisbury. The setting it quite beautiful and abundant with birds and wildlife as well as magnificent mature specimen trees and perennial plants. There's a large natural pond that is surro

More Details
4649 sq ft  11 Bedrooms 6 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 42 Looks Pond Way

IMG_1969
$2,095,000 - Single Family

A magical location on a magical Island - As beautiful and unique as all of Martha's Vineyard is, there are very special spots that exceed expectations. This property is one of them. Tucked away off Music Street down a winding road it sits on the edge of Look's Pond. The h

More Details
3041 sq ft  5 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 63 Boghouse Way

IMG_1969
$3,250,000 - Single Family

Spectacular waterfront setting on Vineyard Sound with private sandy beach. Enjoy unobstructed waterviews from almost every corner of this 2.0 acre site. Built in 1910, this home features Old-Vineyard charm and boasts 8 bedrooms. Enjoy as-is or create your Vineyard dream ho

More Details
2745 sq ft  8 Bedrooms 5 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 395 Lamberts Cove Road

IMG_1969
$1,600,000 - Single Family

Wonderful Lambert's Cove location near the beach and Seth's Pond. Historic home built by Bartimus Luce in 1859, the first homestead constructed on Lambert's Cove. Set privately off the road and flanked by mature trees and old granite stonewalls, this gracious home has been c

More Details
2600 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 179 Pond Road

IMG_1969
$2,995,000 - Single Family

Exquisite home with swimming pool in the perfect location in West Tisbury! Set on one of the rarely offered field view properties in Deep Bottom Pond, this gracious residence in one of the Island’s most sought after enclaves exudes quality at every turn. Constructed by not

More Details
4625 sq ft  5 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 25 Luce Farm Road

IMG_1969
$3,100,000 - Single Family

Brand-new 4,100 sq ft home on 6.2 acres located at the upper end of Indian Hill Road, a short distance past the picture postcard vistas offered by Arrowhead Farm - the quintessential West Tisbury landscape. Architect-designed 5-bedroom home with swimming pool is under constr

More Details
4107 sq ft  5 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 74 Pond Road

IMG_1969
$1,559,000 - Single Family

Located in the highly desirable Deep Bottom Pond Association, offering both tennis and deeded access to Tisbury Great Pond, no detail was overlooked or amenity missed at this expansive custom built four bedroom home. The open floor plan, oversized deck with hot tub, and gen

More Details
4194 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 40 Norton Farm Road

IMG_1969
$2,200,000 - Single Family

A COUNTRY MANOR HIGH ON A HILL – Designed by owners who understand that elegance and relaxation can co-exist. A graceful stone wall and circular drive create a sophisticated setting on a large parcel of land. The community provides two private beaches within a ½ mile of

More Details
3664 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 14 Mayhew Norton Road

IMG_1969
$1,375,000 - Single Family

Perched high and offering views across Vineyard Sound, this rustic farmhouse, brimming with character from the newly finished wide plank pine floors to the exposed post and beam detail, is a home for all seasons. An over-sized timber frame barn, ideal for an artistic alcove

More Details
1311 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 20 Middle Road

IMG_1969
$1,250,000 - Multi-Family

This charming home, set off by a hand-stacked stone wall, is on much sought-after Middle Road and will surprise you with the contemporary flair with which the current owners renovated just a few years ago. The lot is 1.4 acres in size and lies close to the heart of West Tisb

More Details
2516 sq ft  5 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 24 Black Brook Crossing

IMG_1969
$1,775,000 - Single Family

Peace and tranquility on a picturesque and quiet lane within the Longview section of Lambert’s Cove. Enjoy easy access to Lambert’s Cove Beach, Seth’s Pond and the Land Bank Preserve at Ice House Pond, along with tranquil walking trails. This contemporary home with its

More Details
5680 sq ft  6 Bedrooms 5 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 5 Pine Lane

IMG_1969
$950,000 - Single Family

Unique Main House-Guest House Compound on 1.9 lovely wooded acres provides both privacy and a wonderful nature experience with mature landscaping. Built in 1980 and remodeled in 1989, the Main house provides a single-story, 2000 square foot open floor plan with 3 bedrooms, 2

More Details
2419 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 111 Oak Lane

IMG_1969
$1,595,000 - Single Family

Spectacular custom designed Contemporary Farmhouse retreat sited on a 2 acre lot. This energy-efficient home includes triple pane windows, double framed construction, central air, wide plank white oak hardwood floors, a 4 bedroom, 2.5 bathroom main house and a detached over

More Details
3123 sq ft  5 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 80 Obed Daggett Road

IMG_1969
$1,350,000 - Single Family

Tucked away in a coveted area of the north shore with deeded beach access close by, this contemporary home offers expansive space and light with an open floor plan and soaring ceilings in the common areas. Upstairs living and dining room connect to a screened porch and sun d

More Details
2365 sq ft  5 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 14 Music Street

IMG_1969
$1,325,000 - Single Family

This Music Street beauty has been tastefully renovated and expanded over the years. Set back off the road, allowing lots of parking off street. An arbor and brick walk lead you past the gazebo and through the gardens to the covered front porch. The first floor of this home

More Details
1943 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 9 South Pond Road

IMG_1969
$2,000,000 - Single Family

Exceptional custom Rosbeck built home in Deep bottom Pond area of West Tisbury. The entrance opens into the great room which features vaulted ceilings and fireplace, a perfect area for family gatherings and entertaining. The open dining room and kitchen overlooks the gunnit

More Details
3419 sq ft  5 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 62 Otis Bassett Road

IMG_1969
$799,000 - Single Family

VERY interesting property on a lovely lot in West Tisbury. Originally purchased as a modest two bedroom home, the SELLER has created an extensive addition to transform this home. The original structure houses the kitchen, living room, dining room, a full bath, a laundry ro

More Details
2268 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 19 Millstone Lane

IMG_1969
$785,000 - Single Family

Located near beautiful Lambert's Cove Beach, this sweet West Tisbury home is ready and waiting for you! Offered fully furnished~turnkey with several rentals in place for July & August, this property gives you the opportunity to use the home for your own personal use this su

More Details
1735 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 135 Middle Point Road

IMG_1969
$1,649,000 - Land

Tisbury Great Pond ~ A superb parcel that stretches from Thumb Cove to Middle Cove. Six lushly treed acres with direct water frontage on Thumb Cove. Enjoy access to the Pond and boat to a pristine south shore barrier beach for swimming and beaching, recreational fishing and

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 25 Carls Way

IMG_1969
$995,000 - Single Family

Vineyard retreat offered for sale for the first time in many generations, 25 Carls Way is a level 3.1 acre property with a 3 bedroom/2 bathroom ranch style home with a full/finished basement, that's walking distance to your private deeded West Tisbury Great Pond access and T

More Details
1040 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 49 Kaitlyn Farm Way

IMG_1969
$460,000 - Land

Wooded lot 400 to 500 feet deep, located on a very quiet dead end cul-de-sac, with a total of four, 3 acre lots in the subdivision. Includes underground electric, phone and cable to lot corner. The left side of the lot has a continuous swale from front to back, which can a

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 54 Mayhew Norton Road

IMG_1969
$1,295,000 - Single Family

This lovely, unique home, nestled at the top of enchanting Indian Hill road, is warm with country charm and historic character. Recent extensive renovations include new windows, kitchen, bathroom and heating system, making this home comfortable for year round living. A cover

More Details
1747 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 221 & 223 John Cottle Road

IMG_1969
$9,950,000 - Single Family

Paul’s Point, one of the most treasured shorelines on Martha’s Vineyard, known for its sandy shores, emerald waters and remarkable privacy, is home to this wondrous ocean front property. Perfectly manicured yet whimsical grounds sprawl over 8 acres with beetlebung groves

More Details
3864 sq ft  7 Bedrooms 5 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 65 Trotters Lane

IMG_1969
$2,150,000 - Single Family

Pastoral, private, and peaceful... An amazing locations not far from all the island has to offer. Located on a paved road on 9.5 acres of land, this spacious 4,000+ sf home features four bedrooms and four and a half baths with expansion possibilities. This post and beam styl

More Details
4090 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 667 Old County Road

IMG_1969
$975,000 - Single Family

This sunny home sits on 2.43 acres in the historic district of West Tisbury. The property is conveniently located off Old County Road and is just a short walk to the Library and Alley’s Store. Extensively renovated by Hutker & Associates in 1996 and 2010, the house featu

More Details
1564 sq ft  2 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 17 Otis Bassett Road

IMG_1969
$1,329,900 - Single Family

From the moment you enter this property, one is struck by the beautiful landscaping and high end finishes of this custom home. From the inviting gourmet kitchen / family room with gas fireplace to the private MBR wing and spacious studio above the attached two car garage, th

More Details
3678 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 655 Old County Road

IMG_1969
$839,000 - Single Family

This story book cottage has many unique features. It is nestled into gently sloping grounds and surrounded by a landscaped lawn with many ornamental trees and flowers creating a beautiful outdoor space. This location offers close proximity to West Tisbury Village and all the

More Details
2450 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 556 Edgartown West Tisbury Road

IMG_1969
$715,000 - Single Family

If you are looking for a property with character, "The Suzie Scott House" has more than you can imagine. Built in circa 1850, the current owner purchased this well maintained home as part of a long time family owned Estate. This sweet Antique sits on 1.4 acres with several o

More Details
1428 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 20 Leona Lane

IMG_1969
$1,175,000 - Single Family

Sunny contemporary home in Nat's Farm offers a central kitchen/dining/living area with cathedral ceilings, living room with fireplace and granite seat, wood floors and a row of glass doors and windows overlooking the South facing sun deck and grassy lawn. Master bedroom sui

More Details
2338 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 666 Old County Road

IMG_1969
$1,975,000 - Multi-Family

House & Guest House! Beautifully designed and built 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home located in the heart of West Tisbury Village. Sited on 4.5 acres, this gracious home has beautiful wood floors, a gourmet kitchen that is any cooks joy, top of the line appliances, granite counter t

More Details
3611 sq ft  6 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 62 Pond Road

IMG_1969
$1,699,000 - Single Family

Classic Deep Bottom Pond shingled style 4,500 square foot custom designed home. Open floor plan with wood floors and central air-conditioning. There is a first floor Master Suite, powder room, gourmet kitchen and separate sunny breakfast nook, formal living room, spacio

More Details
5100 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 62 Pond Road

IMG_1969
$1,699,000 - Single Family

This custom home is beautifully designed and built for today's living. The main house has a spacious and casual floor plan that offers a design perfect for large families, entertaining and summer guests. Features include a grand living room with cathedral ceiling, granite fi

More Details
4589 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 335 Lamberts Cove Road

IMG_1969
$1,495,000 - Single Family

Restored Lambert's Cove Landmark Martha’s Vineyard 1841 Church and Parsonage are an iconic and historic landmark along Lambert’s Cove Road. The property has been thoughtfully and meticulously renovated, staying true to the original architecture, restoring and carefully

More Details
2714 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 4 Stonewood Lane

IMG_1969
$989,000 - Single Family

This Replica 1760 Saltbox has been nicely designed and built. Many nice features include a great room with cathedral ceiling, skylights, a wood burning fireplace, a Jotul wood stove and french doors that lead to an open deck. The kitchen has plenty of work space and cabinets

More Details
1992 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 142 Otis Bassett Road

IMG_1969
$739,000 - Single Family

Stylish Contemporary ranch. A perfect house as a rental investment property, a retirement home, or for a small family. It is easily maintained and is almost completely a new house. Some of the new features besides windows, elec., plumbing, roof and sunroom etc., include a d

More Details
1316 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 56 Willow Tree Hollow

IMG_1969
$949,000 - Single Family

COMPLETELY RENOVATED IN WEST TISBURY. Willow Tree Hollow is a quiet road located in the heart of West Tisbury close to Alley's General Store, 7a foods and just a short drive to Longpoint Beach. Located on 4.14 acres, this home has undergone a complete high-end renovation b

More Details
1600 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 160 Plum Bush Point Road

IMG_1969
$2,500,000 - Land

*South Shore * Waterfront * Tiah’s Cove * West Tisbury * Come have the perfect island experience…you may fall in love with the natural surroundings, the way the Vineyard used to be…yet easy access to West Tisbury Center, Edgartown, airport and golf courses…you could

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 160 Plum Bush Point Road

IMG_1969
$2,750,000 - Land

Waterfront building lot and Quansoo Beach ~ The Seller has agreed to include his Quansoo Beach lot with the building lot for price of $2,750,000. Please call if you have any questions. This peaceful and serene spot on Tisbury Great Pond is awaiting your imagination. A 6.4 ac

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 4 Windy Way

IMG_1969
$5,399,000 - Single Family

Set on the highest island point on Makonikey in West Tisbury, this property’s commanding, panoramic view is one of the best on the North Shore and possibly the whole island. At 108’ above sea level, these breathtaking water views across Vineyard Sound, the Elizabeth Isl

More Details
2651 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - Western Parcel at South Shore Estates

IMG_1969
$20,500,000 - Single Family

This 30.3 +/- acre oceanfront parcel contains two lots. It features a one- bedroom beach house perched on stilts with direct ocean views and exclusive use of 300’ of private beach within walking distance from the beach house. The 17.6 +/- acre front lot contains the beach

More Details
600 sq ft  1 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - Eastern Parcel at South Shore Estates

IMG_1969
$24,500,000 - Single Family

This 29.1+/- acre oceanfront property features two lots and 300’ of frontage on the Atlantic Ocean. The 16.6 +/- acre front lot contains a four-bedroom residence with salt-water swimming pool, hot tub, Har-Tru tennis court, and an impressive underground 12,000 bottle-capac

More Details
4392 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 55 Naushon Road

IMG_1969
$2,150,000 - Land

Pristine 3.9 acre waterfront building lot with nearly 200’ of frontage on Vineyard Sound. Survey and staking has been completed with potential building envelope already defined. Located within the exclusive Upper Makonikey association, all you’ll need is your imaginati

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 32 Pine Lane Estates

IMG_1969
$425,000 - Land

This lot is beautifully treed and bucolic with a huge Christmas tree in the center of the lot. The lot unwraps to a deep and large expanse, it must be walked to be appreciated. 8 bedrooms allowed on the lot. Very little noise with extraordinary privacy. Total of 13 lots sur

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 5 Murphys Road

IMG_1969
$1,625,000 - Single Family

Magical West Tisbury - Surrounded by conservation land, exquisite pastoral and pond views, and privacy. Attached greenhouse, your very own artist studio make up this enchanting 3,200 sq. ft. home. Walk across the road to Mermaid Farm or take a hike on the hundreds of acres o

More Details
3180 sq ft  5 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 0 Off Edgartown Road Harpoon Lane

IMG_1969
$535,000 - Land

West Tisbury privacy with convenient access to Alley's General Store, Tiah's Cove, and the old Ag Hall and the State Forest bike path which abuts the property. Septic and well will need to be installed under buyers expense. The listing Broker is related to Seller.

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 5 Murphys Road

IMG_1969
$1,625,000 - Single Family

Once home to one of the Islands most renowned artists, this six bedroom expanded farmhouse has blended modern amenities with the  charm of an historical home. A place where permanent conservation restrictions create a pastoral environment, expansive rooms with overs

More Details
3180 sq ft  6 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms