PO Box 26, Menemsha, MA 02552

PO Box 26, Menemsha, MA 02552

Find Your Home

West Tisbury – 5 Murphys Lane

Murphy Exterior
On Sale
$1,625,000 - Single Family Home

Magical West Tisbury – Surrounded by conservation land with exquisite pastoral views and privacy, this nearly 3200 square foot former homestead of Island artist, Stan Murphy, is the ideal Vineyard property. The view out the back is of a gorgeous pond and grazing cows.

More Details
3180 sq ft  6 Bedrooms 3.5 Bathrooms 1 Garages
Choose Feiner Real Estate to work for you as a your  Buyer's Agent for any of these additional available properties. Call us today at 508 645-2658, or email, feinermv@gmail.com, for more information or to arrange a showing.

West Tisbury - 135 Middle Point Road

IMG_1969
$1,649,000 - Land

Tisbury Great Pond ~ A superb parcel that stretches from Thumb Cove to Middle Cove. Six lushly treed acres with direct water frontage on Thumb Cove. Enjoy access to the Pond and boat to a pristine south shore barrier beach for swimming and beaching, recreational fishing and

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 25 Carls Way

IMG_1969
$1,200,000 - Single Family

Offered for sale for the first time in many generations, 25 Carls Way is a level 3.1 acre property with a 3 bedroom/2 bathroom ranch style home with a full/finished basement, that's walking distance to your private deeded West Tisbury Great Pond access and Town Center. The

More Details
1040 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 11 Chappaquiddick Avenue

IMG_1969
$2,495,000 - Single Family

Enjoy Up and Down Island living at this unique, 3 acre parcel with two houses in two towns! In Vineyard Haven you’ll find a 2,475 square foot, four bedroom, three and one half bath house with water views to Vineyard Sound. Walk across the yard to West Tisbury and you’ll

More Details
3673 sq ft  5 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 79 Merry Farm Road

IMG_1969
$1,200,000 - Multi-Family

Set thoughtfully on over 3 acres in a quiet, central location off the main road but not far from town's conveniences, this multi-family property lends itself beautifully to uses appreciated by Islanders and visitors alike. The property was designed and crafted by a boat bui

More Details
3390 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 49 Kaitlyn Farm Way

IMG_1969
$450,000 - Land

Wooded lot 400 to 500 feet deep, located on a very quiet dead end cul-de-sac, with a total of four, 3 acre lots in the subdivision. Includes underground electric, phone and cable to lot corner. The left side of the lot has a continuous swale from front to back, which can a

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 43 Tiasquam Road

IMG_1969
$1,145,000 - Single Family

Rarely found and incredibly private, this up-island home is perched atop a hill overlooking Glimmerglass pond, in a landscape filled with towering beech and oak trees, and ancient boulders. Enjoy the magic of this setting from a pond-side deck listening to the gentle sounds

More Details
1667 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 54 Mayhew Norton Road

IMG_1969
$1,295,000 - Single Family

This lovely, unique home, nestled at the top of enchanting Indian Hill road, is warm with country charm and historic character. Recent extensive renovations include new windows, kitchen, bathroom and heating system, making this home comfortable for year round living. A cover

More Details
1747 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 221 & 223 John Cottle Road

IMG_1969
$9,950,000 - Single Family

Paul’s Point, one of the most treasured shorelines on Martha’s Vineyard, known for its sandy shores, emerald waters and remarkable privacy, is home to this wondrous ocean front property. Perfectly manicured yet whimsical grounds sprawl over 8 acres with beetlebung groves

More Details
3864 sq ft  7 Bedrooms 5 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 65 Trotters Lane

IMG_1969
$2,150,000 - Single Family

Pastoral, private, and peaceful... An amazing locations not far from all the island has to offer. Located on a paved road on 9.5 acres of land, this spacious 4,000+ sf home features four bedrooms and four and a half baths with expansion possibilities. This post and beam styl

More Details
4090 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 655 Old County Road

IMG_1969
$895,000 - Single Family

This story book cottage has many unique features. It is nestled into gently sloping grounds and surrounded by a landscaped lawn with many ornamental trees and flowers creating a beautiful outdoor space. This location offers close proximity to West Tisbury Village and all the

More Details
2450 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 556 Edgartown West Tisbury Road

IMG_1969
$715,000 - Single Family

If you are looking for a property with character, "The Suzie Scott House" has more than you can imagine. Built in circa 1850, the current owner purchased this well maintained home as part of a long time family owned Estate. This sweet Antique sits on 1.4 acres with several o

More Details
1428 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 666 Old County Road

IMG_1969
$1,975,000 - Multi-Family

House & Guest House! Beautifully designed and built 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home located in the heart of West Tisbury Village. Sited on 4.5 acres, this gracious home has beautiful wood floors, a gourmet kitchen that is any cooks joy, top of the line appliances, granite counter t

More Details
3611 sq ft  6 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 62 Pond Road

IMG_1969
$1,749,000 - Single Family

Classic Deep Bottom Pond shingled style 4,500 square foot custom designed home. Open floor plan with wood floors and central air-conditioning. There is a first floor Master Suite, powder room, gourmet kitchen and separate sunny breakfast nook, formal living room, spacio

More Details
5100 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 62 Pond Road

IMG_1969
$1,749,000 - Single Family

This custom home is beautifully designed and built for today's living. The main house has a spacious and casual floor plan that offers a design perfect for large families, entertaining and summer guests. Features include a grand living room with cathedral ceiling, granite fi

More Details
4589 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 335 Lamberts Cove Road

IMG_1969
$1,675,000 - Single Family

Restored Lambert's Cove Landmark Martha’s Vineyard 1841 Church and Parsonage are an iconic and historic landmark along Lambert’s Cove Road. The property has been thoughtfully and meticulously renovated, staying true to the original architecture, restoring and carefully

More Details
2714 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 4 Stonewood Lane

IMG_1969
$989,000 - Single Family

This Replica 1760 Saltbox has been nicely designed and built. Many nice features include a great room with cathedral ceiling, skylights, a wood burning fireplace, a Jotul wood stove and french doors that lead to an open deck. The kitchen has plenty of work space and cabinets

More Details
1992 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 142 Otis Bassett Road

IMG_1969
$767,000 - Single Family

Stylish Contemporary ranch. Features include a dramatic 11' cathedral ceiling in living room w/ a corner gas fireplace w/black marble mantle, custom lighting. Eye-catching kitchen with gray cabinets, quartz counters and Island. Stone ceramic tile in both the kitchen and di

More Details
1316 sq ft  3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 90 Manaquayak Road

IMG_1969
$6,495,000 - Single Family

Lambert's Cove Inn, Farm, and Restaurant. A premier 17 room luxury boutique hotel and award winning 70 seat restaurant. Just under 8 acres of sprawling grounds, including beautiful gardens, salt mineral pool and spa, tennis courts, and 2 luxury guest cottages. The Inn can be

More Details
8575 sq ft  17 Bedrooms 17 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 56 Willow Tree Hollow

IMG_1969
$949,000 - Single Family

COMPLETELY RENOVATED. Willow Tree Hollow is a quiet road located in the heart of West Tisbury close to Alley's General Store, 7a foods and just a short drive to Longpoint Beach. Located on 4.14 acres, this home is undergoing a complete renovation both inside and out. The

More Details
1600 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 160 Plum Bush Point Road

IMG_1969
$2,950,000 - Land

This peaceful and serene spot on Tisbury Great Pond is awaiting your imagination. A 6.4 acre waterfront parcel has +/-365 ft of frontage on Tiah's Cove across from the Land Bank Sepiessa Point Reservation of 173.7 acres. Fishing, clamming oystering, kayaking, boating and sw

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 160 Plum Bush Point Road

IMG_1969
$3,250,000 - Land

Waterfront building lot and Quansoo Beach ~ The Seller has agreed to include his Quansoo Beach lot with the building lot for price of $3,250,000. Please call if you have any questions. This peaceful and serene spot on Tisbury Great Pond is awaiting your imagination. A 6.4 ac

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 215 Great Plains Road

IMG_1969
$849,000 - Single Family

Terrific, sunny, passive solar 4- bedroom home situated on 1.46 acres of cleared meadowland. Just a five minute drive to Lambert's Cove beach. Features include an enclosed sunporch, radiant 5-zone heating system, fireplace and separate wood stove, 2-car garage, alarm system

More Details
2355 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 4 Windy Way

IMG_1969
$5,850,000 - Single Family

Set on the highest island point on Makonikey in West Tisbury, this property’s commanding, panoramic view is one of the best on the North Shore and possibly the whole island. At 108’ above sea level, these breathtaking water views across Vineyard Sound, the Elizabeth Isl

More Details
2651 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 90 Manaquayak Road

IMG_1969
$6,495,000 - Commercial

Lambert's Cove Inn, Farm, and Restaurant. A premier 17 bedroom luxury boutique hotel and award winning 70 seat restaurant. Just under 8 acres of sprawling grounds, including beautiful gardens, salt mineral pool and spa, tennis courts, and 2 luxury guest cottages, as well as

More Details
8575 sq ft  17 Bedrooms 17 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - Parcel C at South Shore Estates

IMG_1969
$20,500,000 - Single Family

This 30± acre oceanfront parcel with two lots features an idyllic one-bedroom beach house with direct ocean views and exclusive use of 300’ of private beach within walking distance from the beach house. A building site for a two-story main residence north of the beach hou

More Details
700 sq ft  1 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - Parcel D at South Shore Estates

IMG_1969
$24,500,000 - Single Family

This 29 +/ acre oceanfront property features a four-bedroom residence with salt-water swimming pool, hot tub, Har-Tru tennis court, and an impressive, underground 10,000 bottle-capacity wine cellar. The home was designed by Gary Graham of Graham Meus, Inc. to highlight the h

More Details
5600 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 55 Naushon Road

IMG_1969
$2,150,000 - Land

Pristine 3.9 acre waterfront building lot with nearly 200’ of frontage on Vineyard Sound. Survey and staking has been completed with potential building envelope already defined. Located within the exclusive Upper Makonikey association, all you’ll need is your imaginati

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 401 Lamberts Cove Road

IMG_1969
$1,100,000 - Multi-Family

If you are looking for the charm that only a vintage home can offer - this property is for you! The current owners have tapped into their accomplished artistic talents and their endless energies and created a wonderful, laid-back, casual elegance at this property that is jus

More Details
3148 sq ft  7 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 32 Pine Lane Estates

IMG_1969
$500,000 - Land

This lot is beautifully treed and bucolic with a huge Christmas tree in the center of the lot. The lot unwraps to a deep and large expanse, it must be walked to be appreciated. 8 bedrooms allowed on the lot. Very little noise with extraordinary privacy. Total of 13 lots sur

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 94 Norton Farm Road

IMG_1969
$2,195,000 - Single Family

Finely crafted Upper Makonikey Home on 8.5 Acres with access to a sandy association beach on Vineyard Sound.  This custom built 4 bedroom home features over 3,700 sq. ft. of living space and includes an elegant cooks kitchen, open dining room for large gatherings, living ro

More Details
3700 sq ft  4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 5 Murphy's Road

IMG_1969
$1,625,000 - Single Family

Magical West Tisbury - Surrounded by conservation land, (MV Landbank Trail has been moved to other side of the driveway). Exquisite pastoral and pond views with privacy. The house is almost 3200 sq. ft. and while move in ready, would be an awesome remodel project bringing gl

More Details
3180 sq ft  5 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 0 Off Edgartown Road Harpoon Lane

IMG_1969
$535,000 - Land

West Tisbury privacy with convenient access to Alley's General Store, Tiah's Cove, and the old Ag Hall and the State Forest bike path which abuts the property. Septic and well will need to be installed under buyers expense. The listing Broker is related to Seller.

More Details
0 sq ft  0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

West Tisbury - 5 Murphys Road

IMG_1969
$1,625,000 - Single Family

Once home to one of the Islands most renowned artists, this six bedroom expanded farmhouse has blended modern amenities with the  charm of an historical home. A place where permanent conservation restrictions create a pastoral environment, expansive rooms with overs

More Details
3180 sq ft  6 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms