PO Box 26, Menemsha, MA 02552

PO Box 26, Menemsha, MA 02552

Available Property

Edgartown - 213 Meetinghouse Way

On Sale $1,715,000 - Single Family
2388 sq ft 5 Bedrooms3 Bathrooms6 Garages Print this page

A RARE OPPORTUNITY TO OWN A KATAMA FAMILY COMPOUND. Close enough to hear the distant waves on South Beach, two distinct residential spaces, recently renovated, and meticulously maintained. The large corner lot allows for expansion, consider a pool and pool house to complete this ideal family compound, or use the houses separately to benefit from a rental income and your own island retreat. Both offer sophisticated design and custom features, open floor plans, cathedral ceilings, wood floors, granite counters, finely tiled baths, stainless steel appliances and outdoor showers. Yet each is completely private with its own unique and delightful details, inside and out. The main house features wide-planked floors, paneled wood fireplace, and post and beam architecture, all recently painted to create a light and airy interior. A newly renovated first floor bedroom suite offers a custom walk-in closet, laundry, and chic tiled bath, radiant heat and glass shower. Enjoy morning coffee on the front wrap-around porch and dinner under the stars on the large back deck. Behind a grove of mature evergreens, the guest house added in 1984, is a surprising oasis. Larger than is allowed by zoning today, completely renovated in 2011 with custom kitchen and bath, to live well as its own year-round residence. The sun filled interior opens onto a stunning fenced courtyard showcasing dramatic gardens, a large bluestone patio, and a charming outdoor dining area. Six bedrooms possible with sewer tie-in from Vickers, there is a solid rental history and 2019 rentals for the main house already in place. All conveniently located a short distance from South Beach, the newly paved bike paths along Meetinghouse Way, or from Herring Creek Road into historic Edgartown Village. Furnishings available as separate purchase.

Concrete crawl space - insulated with dehumidifier.

1st Floor
MAIN HOUSE: To the left of the entry, cherry floors throughout the open floorplan dining and living room with accent wall showcasing a wood burning fireplace. Granite counters and slate tile floor in the kitchen connecting to the back deck, outdoor shower and pergola. To the right, a new master bedroom suite with custom walk-in closet, laundry and shared bath that also opens to the living room. GUEST HOUSE: French doors open into a foyer, the door to the kitchen, and the open living room, dining room with wide glass doors highlighting the outdoor living spaces and garden courtyard beyond. On the other side of the entry, a den for overflow guests, laundry, and a full bath.

2nd Floor
MAIN HOUSE: Two bedrooms, a full bath, and a loft-style den for overflow guests. Wide pine floors and open gallery overlooking the living room below. GUEST HOUSE: To either side of the landing, a master bedroom with dramatic arched window and a guest bedroom that share an en suite half bath.

Listed by Sandpiper Realty

Property Map

Wendy Swolinsky

Wendy Swolinsky

Wendy Swolinsky had been living on Martha’s Vineyard for 34 years where she raised her daughter. In 1998 she got her Massachusetts Real Estate license and began working as a real estate professional specializing in the up island towns of Gay Head, Chilmark, and West Tisbury. In addition she released her entrepreneurial spirit and started Book-A-Boat in 1999 where she filled a niche market providing water access to fisherman, kayakers and sailors island wide.

Please contact the office for an agent to help you.

  • Office : 508-645-2658